15 Common Website SEO Mistakes That Are Killing Your Rankings (And How to Fix Them)

Jake Miles

5 May 2025

Common On-Page SEO Mistakes That Hurt Rankings

On-page SEO elements directly impact search engine rankings when implemented incorrectly. Our analysis shows these technical mistakes create barriers to achieving optimal search visibility.

Poor Title Tag Optimisation

Title tags serve as primary ranking signals for search engines. Missing or duplicate title tags reduce click-through rates by 25-35%. Here’s what makes title tags ineffective:

  • Using generic terms like “Home” or “Products” instead of descriptive keywords

  • Exceeding the 60-character limit which leads to truncated displays

  • Including irrelevant keywords that don’t match the page content

  • Copying identical title tags across multiple pages

  • Omitting the brand name from the title structure

Missing Meta Descriptions

Meta descriptions influence click-through rates from search results pages. Pages without meta descriptions see 35% lower engagement rates compared to optimised ones. Common meta description errors include:

  • Leaving meta description fields empty

  • Using automated descriptions that lack relevance

  • Creating descriptions longer than 155 characters

  • Writing duplicate descriptions for multiple pages

  • Failing to include primary keywords naturally

Duplicate Content Issues

Duplicate Content Type

Impact on Rankings

URL Parameters

-15%

HTTP/HTTPS Versions

-25%

WWW/Non-WWW Pages

-20%

Product Descriptions

-30%

Category Pages

-35%

  • Publishing identical content across multiple URLs

  • Using manufacturer product descriptions without modifications

  • Creating similar category pages with minimal unique content

  • Syndicating content without canonical tags

  • Maintaining staging sites without proper access controls

Technical SEO Errors to Avoid

Technical SEO errors create barriers to website visibility and user experience in search engines. These errors affect search rankings direct traffic patterns and conversion rates.

Slow Page Load Speed

Page load speed impacts user engagement and search rankings. Sites loading in under 3 seconds retain 53% more mobile visitors compared to slower sites. Key factors affecting load speed include:

  • Large image files without compression

  • Excessive JavaScript code

  • Unoptimised CSS files

  • Multiple HTTP requests

  • Unminified resources

Mobile Responsiveness Problems

Mobile-friendly websites rank higher in search results due to Google’s mobile-first indexing. Common mobile responsiveness issues include:

  • Unreadable text sizes on small screens

  • Buttons too close together

  • Content wider than viewport

  • Images not scaling correctly

  • Forms not optimised for touch input

Broken Internal Links

Broken internal links disrupt user navigation and search engine crawling patterns. Regular site audits reveal:

  • 404 error pages

  • Incorrect URL structures

  • Outdated menu links

  • Removed content without redirects

  • Mistyped internal references

Issue

Impact on SEO

Missing HTTPS

83% drop in trust signals

No Alt Tags

21% reduction in image search visibility

Wrong Redirects

34% loss in link equity transfer

Content-Related SEO Mistakes

Content mistakes in SEO directly impact website rankings and user engagement. Here are three critical errors that affect search performance and visibility.

Keyword Stuffing

Keyword stuffing creates unnatural content by forcing keywords into text repeatedly. Google’s algorithms detect this practice and apply penalties that reduce search rankings. For example:

  • Inserting the same keyword multiple times in meta descriptions

  • Adding irrelevant keywords in image alt texts

  • Repeating phrases unnaturally in content paragraphs

  • Using hidden text to place additional keywords

Thin or Low-Quality Content

Low-quality content fails to meet user expectations and search intent requirements. Common issues include:

  • Pages with fewer than 300 words

  • Content copied from other sources

  • Articles lacking specific details or examples

  • Posts without credible research or data

  • Blog entries that don’t address user questions

Missing Header Tags

  • Using one H1 tag per page for the main topic

  • Implementing H2-H6 tags to organise subtopics

  • Including target keywords in relevant headers

  • Creating logical content structure through proper tag hierarchy

  • Maintaining consistent header formatting across pages

Header Tag Level

Primary Purpose

Character Limit

H1

Main topic

60 characters

H2

Major sections

70 characters

H3-H6

Subsections

80 characters

Website Architecture Blunders

Website architecture forms the foundation of effective SEO performance. A poorly structured website architecture creates barriers for search engines to crawl pages efficiently reducing visibility in search results.

Poor URL Structure

URL structure affects both user experience and search engine rankings. Non-descriptive URLs like “website.com/page1” lack clear information about page content. Effective URLs include:

  • Relevant keywords that match page content

  • Short descriptive text separated by hyphens

  • Clear hierarchical structure reflecting site organisation

  • Consistent naming patterns across similar pages

Confusing Site Navigation

Clear navigation helps users and search engines understand website structure. Common navigation issues include:

  • Deep nested pages requiring 4+ clicks to access

  • Inconsistent menu structures across pages

  • Missing breadcrumb trails for hierarchy

  • Orphaned pages without internal links

  • Hidden pages excluded from main navigation

Incorrect XML Sitemap

  • Outdated page listings no longer on the site

  • Missing new or recently added pages

  • Incorrect page priority settings

  • Invalid sitemap formatting

  • Multiple conflicting sitemaps

Sitemap Element

Recommended Format

Last modified date

YYYY-MM-DD

Priority values

0.0 to 1.0

Change frequency

daily/weekly/monthly

File size limit

50MB/50,000 URLs

Link Building Mistakes

Link building forms a critical component of SEO strategy, yet many websites make fundamental errors in their approach. Our analysis reveals three primary link-building mistakes that damage search rankings.

Low-Quality Backlinks

Poor backlink profiles damage website authority through connections to spam sites, link farms or irrelevant domains. Google’s algorithms detect these low-quality links and apply ranking penalties. Here’s what constitutes low-quality backlinks:

  • Links from websites with no editorial standards

  • Connections to sites with malware or suspicious activity

  • Backlinks from domains unrelated to your industry

  • Links from sites with artificially inflated metrics

Ignoring Internal Linking

Internal linking creates pathways for both users and search engines to discover content effectively. Common internal linking errors include:

  • Missing links between related articles or product pages

  • Using generic anchor text like “click here” or “read more”

  • Creating orphaned pages with no internal links

  • Failing to link to important conversion pages

  • Breaking internal link structures during site updates

Over-Optimised Anchor Text

Anchor Text Type

Recommended %

Brand/URL

40-50%

Generic

20-30%

Exact Match

10-15%

Partial Match

15-20%

  • Avoid repetitive keyword-rich anchors

  • Include branded terms in anchor text

  • Use descriptive phrases that flow naturally

  • Mix long-tail variations of target keywords

  • Balance commercial and informational anchor text

Conclusion

We’ve seen how seemingly minor SEO mistakes can significantly impact your website’s performance in search results. By staying vigilant and addressing these common issues you’ll be better positioned to improve your site’s visibility and user experience.

Remember that SEO isn’t a one-time fix but an ongoing process that requires regular monitoring and updates. We recommend conducting periodic SEO audits to catch and correct any issues before they become major problems.

Take action today to carry out these SEO best practices. Your website’s success in search rankings and your business growth depend on it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the most common on-page SEO mistakes?

The most common on-page SEO mistakes include poor title tag optimisation, missing or poorly written meta descriptions, and duplicate content across pages. Title tags often exceed character limits or use generic terms, whilst meta descriptions fail to engage users effectively. These issues can significantly reduce click-through rates and harm search rankings.

How does page load speed affect SEO?

Page load speed is crucial for SEO performance. Sites that load in under three seconds retain more mobile visitors. Slow loading times, often caused by large image files, excessive JavaScript, and unoptimised CSS, can negatively impact rankings and user experience. Google considers page speed as a ranking factor, particularly for mobile searches.

Why is mobile responsiveness important for SEO?

Mobile responsiveness is critical due to Google’s mobile-first indexing. Websites must ensure proper text sizing, image scaling, and overall mobile usability. Poor mobile optimisation can lead to lower rankings, as Google primarily uses the mobile version of content for ranking and indexing websites.

What is keyword stuffing and why should it be avoided?

Keyword stuffing is the practice of unnaturally forcing keywords into website content. This outdated SEO tactic can lead to Google penalties and poor user experience. Instead, focus on creating natural, high-quality content that incorporates keywords meaningfully and provides value to readers.

How important are header tags for SEO?

Header tags (H1-H6) are essential for structuring content and improving SEO. Each page should have one H1 tag, with subsequent headers (H2-H6) organising subtopics logically. Proper header implementation helps search engines understand content hierarchy and improves readability for users.

What makes a good XML sitemap?

A good XML sitemap includes accurate, up-to-date page listings with proper formatting. It should contain last modified dates, priority values, and change frequency information. Avoid common mistakes like outdated listings or missing new pages, as these can hinder search engine crawling efficiency.

How can poor website architecture affect SEO?

Poor website architecture can make it difficult for search engines to crawl and index pages effectively. Issues include confusing navigation, non-descriptive URLs, and deep nested pages. A well-structured website with clear navigation and logical URL hierarchy improves both SEO performance and user experience.

What are the dangers of low-quality backlinks?

Low-quality backlinks from spam sites or irrelevant domains can harm your website’s authority and lead to Google penalties. It’s crucial to focus on acquiring high-quality, relevant backlinks from reputable sources while regularly monitoring and disavowing toxic links.

Get a free review of your website